Helpful thread 👍

So basically, I had the same issue with my Model Y. I was worried about cheap materials and rattles, but I ended up going with Spigen and honestly, I'm super satisfied.

1. Go with a brand like Spigen or Basenor; you really can't go wrong with their fit.
2. Get the flocked/felt-lined versions—it looks way more OEM and stops things from sliding around.
3. Make sure it's the sliding version so it doesn't mess with the console lid.

Everything works well and fits perfectly!

For your situation, honestly, I totally get the frustration with that 'abyss' feeling—it’s basically like losing stuff into a black hole lol. Since you're looking for value and fit, I've tried a few over the years and there's a big difference in how they actually hold up day-to-day.

Here's what I recommend based on my experience with the refreshed console:

1. **Felt/Flocked vs. Silicone:** Ngl, the flocked ones like the Spigen Center Console Organizer Tray (Flocked) look way more high-end and match the OEM interior perfectly. They also stop things from rattling around, which is a huge plus. The downside? They’re a pain to clean if you spill something. If you're a neat freak or have kids, the Basenor Model Y Center Console Organizer Tray (Silicone) is probably better since you can literally just rinse it off.

2. **The Hidden Compartment:** You definitely want the Topfit for Tesla Model 3/Y Armrest Hidden Storage Box. It’s super cheap but fits that space under the armrest lid perfectly for things like your registration or some emergency cash.

3. **Sliding Tray Functionality:** Make sure you get one that actually slides smoothly. I’ve seen some cheap ones that gunk up the mechanism. The Scentwedge Tesla Center Console Organizer is a bit pricier but the tolerances are really tight so it doesn't interfere with the sliding lid or the wireless pads at all.

Basically, if you want the best bang for your buck, I'd go with a kit from a brand like Basenor or Spigen. They usually have the best specs and don't feel like flimsy junk. Hope that helps you get organized!! 👍

Been using this for years, no complaints

Oh man, I totally feel u on that abyss... over the years I've tried many setups for my Teslas. Basically, they give u all that space but zero way to manage it. To help narrow it down, are u leaning more towards silicone for easy cleaning, or is matching that flocked OEM look highkey your main priority?? Also, do u plan on using the 12V socket in there much?

Just sharing my experience: so basically, I went through this same struggle last winter when I took delivery of my Model Y in a pretty rainy, humid area. Honestly, I initially thought the flocked organizers like the Topfit Center Console Organizer Tray for Model Y/3 looked way more premium because they match the factory felt, but man, I was so wrong for my specific climate.

I live where it's constantly damp, and those felt-lined ones started smelling kinda musty after I accidentally put a wet umbrella near the console. Plus, the dust... literally impossible to get out. I ended up swapping to the JOARDY Silicone Center Console Organizer Tray for Tesla Model Y/3 Refresh and it was a game changer for me.

* Silicone doesn't rattle at all (major plus!!)
* Super easy to just pull out and rinse if a coffee spill happens
* Actually stays put even when I'm hitting those corners hard

I guess it depends on your local weather, but for me, the silicone felt way more practical than the velvet-style ones, even if they look a bit more 'basic' at first. Maybe consider if you're gonna be dealing with a lot of moisture or dirt where you live? gl! 👍

Same setup here, love it

Interested in this too

> Do you prefer the silicone versions for easy cleaning, or the felt-lined ones for a more premium look?

Respectfully, I'd consider another option because I actually had a pretty bad experience with both of those styles. Not to disagree with the others, but I found the flocked/felt-lined ones are a total nightmare to keep clean—once dust or crumbs get in there, they're basically stuck forever. On the flip side, the cheap silicone ones I tried from random brands were super flimsy and literally started warping after a few weeks in the sun.

Honestly, I'd avoid the super cheap generic kits on Amazon. From a market research perspective, I've noticed the "premium" brands like Jowua or Tesmanian tend to use much better high-temp plastics that wont rattle or melt. I'm lowkey disappointed I wasted money on the budget stuff first. Just be careful with anything that claims to be "universal"—they almost never fit the refreshed sliding console right. gl!

100% agree