Can I add items fro...
 
Notifications
Clear all

[Solved] Can I add items from different websites to one wish list?

5 Posts
6 Users
0 Reactions
124 Views
0
[#3930]
Topic starter

I'm honestly so over having fifty tabs open trying to organize what I need for my new place in Seattle. I'm moving next month and my family keeps asking what I want but it's a total mess. I've got stuff I want from IKEA, some specific kitchen gear from a boutique site called Food52, and then the basic stuff on Amazon. It's driving me crazy because I cant find one place that just lets me put it all together without making people jump through hoops.

I'm looking at a few options right now and cant decide which is less of a headache:

  • MyRegistry: I heard it's the standard but some reviews say the add to list button is buggy on mobile and that would be a total dealbreaker for my mom who isnt tech savvy.
  • GiftHero: It looks way cleaner but I'm worried it wont sync properly if something goes out of stock on the original store site and then people buy stuff that isnt there anymore.
  • Wishybox: I just found this one today, seems simple but maybe too simple?

I need something free since I'm already spending way too much on movers and a deposit. The main thing is that it HAS to have a browser extension because I'm not copying and pasting links manually for 40 different items. Does anyone actually use these things or is there a better way I'm missing? I just want one link to send to everyone so they stop texting me for my address and preferences every five minutes...


5 Answers
12

To add to the point above: i actually disagree slightly since those felt a bit buggy with price syncing. I'm very satisfied with Moonsift after using it for my move last fall. It captures technical metadata way more reliably than others.


10

Like someone mentioned, browser extensions are definitely the most reliable way to sync everything. I've been quite satisfied using GiftHero because it feels more stable than the alternatives. No complaints about how it manages different store links.


3

I used the MyRegistry Browser Button Extension for my last move to keep costs at zero. It handled my IKEA list and items like the Lodge Cast Iron Skillet 12 Inch easily.

  • saves money on service fees
  • one link for the whole family
  • extension is easy to install Its a decent option that works well, though it really depends on your needs for mobile use.


3

To add to the point above: I'm totally with Wayne on the metadata thing. If the scraper doesn't grab the price and stock status correctly, the whole list is useless. In my experience, these browser extensions are only as good as the code behind them, and many of them are honestly pretty lazy.

  • Just go with Blueprint Registry. Their backend is way more stable for syncing and it handles boutique sites way better than the older platforms.
  • If you want a solid alternative, SoKind Registry is technically very sound and doesn't have nearly as many bugs as the bigger names. I've tried many of these over the years and the biggest headache is always when the price doesn't update or the link breaks. You want something with a robust scraper that actually understands site architecture. Most of the free tools are kinda janky, but those two usually stay stable even when sites like IKEA change their layout. Seattle is a great city tho... hope the move goes smooth.


Share: